Tootsie Rolls - Yeah these aren't that bad, they are just the lowest form of halloween candy. I mean, i'd eventually eat them but just not that exciting.
Double Bubble - hated bubble gum (still do) and hated getting these. at least bazooka had a lame comic.
Pennies - WTF? I got those before. Don't be so lazy that you hand out the cash equiv. of a mini-snickers. I can't do much of anything with 4 cents lady.
Good n' Plenty - I never understood these. Did anybody like these damn things? I'm not the biggest licorce fan but I can deal with twizzlers, they are okay.. but good and plenty is only right in one regard.
Toothbrushes, tracts - never got either to my recollection. Then again we didn't live in a neighborhood so i rarely did the actual 'trick or treat' scenerio. Usually i was at a school event and/or a church event. Yeah churches were down on the holiday but they'd have fall festivals every year that were halloween parties with a different name, costumes and all. Anyway even back in the 80s schools probably knew better than to let people hand out tracts, and the churches probably figured they were preaching to the choir.
Pencils, Erasers - Got these occasionally. Yeah not the best but at least they were utilitarian. Better than a good n' plenty.
Stuff I'd add -
Like Niloc mentioned those horrible Orange and Black candies. WTF were those supposed to be? Some horrible inpentrable taffy. Unlike a Sugar Daddy or a Bit o' Honey these were no fun. Took what seemed like days to chew the damn things. I always feared one would choke me to death.
Hershey's Special Dark - can't blame people for having these as they always show up in those hersheys assortments.. but it was always the last candy left. It was edible but you'd always have these last.
Palmer Peanut Butter Cups - Palmer was like the Gobots of candy. You'd think you scored a lot of decent stuff until you realized a lot of those gold cups weren't reeses. This stuff was pretty cheap and gross.
Spider Rings - yeah i love skull rings and one or two was a nice sign that it was halloween. However by the end of the night you likely had 3 dozen of the things and this isn't an item that gets exponentially better in numbers.